Which US States Joke the Most on Reddit? An AI Ranking Explained
Reddit rewards upvotes instead of likes or follower counts, and much of its activity happens anonymously. That combination makes jokes a central part of how posts gain attention. This page explains how an AI-based review of state subreddits measured attempted humor, how activity was separated from humor, and what patterns emerged across US states.
How the ranking was built
For each state, the top 50 threads from the year were collected, and their top-level comments were passed to an AI model, Mistral 7B, with the thread topic supplied as context. Each comment was labelled simply as a joke or not a joke. The share of comments labelled as jokes became the humor score for that state. This followed an earlier country-level analysis, in which the United States was already among the countries with a high share of attempted jokes; the state-level work applies the same approach within the US.
What was counted and what was left out
The dataset covered 2,700 threads and 209,806 top-level comments. Three kinds of comment were left out before classification:
- Replies to another comment rather than direct responses to the thread, because judging them against the thread title alone would lose conversational context. In Reddit data these are marked by a parent identifier beginning with t1_.
- Deleted or removed comments, typically shown with text enclosed in square brackets.
- Comments containing a link, since a link may carry context the model cannot infer, and providing evidence usually signals a serious point rather than a joke.
These exclusions keep the classification focused on standalone, direct responses whose intent can be read from the comment plus the thread topic.
First, how vocal each state is
Before comparing humor, activity was measured separately by averaging the number of comments per thread for each state. That baseline matters: a state can generate many comments without a high share of them being jokes, and a quieter state can still have a high joke share. Reading the two measures together prevents volume from being mistaken for humor.
Then, which states attempt the most jokes
On the humor measure, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Arkansas led the ranking. The share of attempted jokes declined gradually across most states, then dropped more sharply for the bottom three: Hawaii, Maine and the Virgin Islands. The contrast at the bottom is instructive. Maine was the third most active state by comments per thread, yet ranked near the bottom for jokes, which points to comparatively serious discussion. Hawaii and the Virgin Islands were also not prominent in the most active commenters, so their low humor shares come from a quieter base.
What the map suggests
On the map, more humorous and less humorous states tend to sit next to each other in broad regions rather than appearing scattered at random. One possible explanation is geography: features such as mountains, rivers and deserts can separate communities and allow distinct cultural habits to develop. Because almost every US state primarily speaks English, language is held roughly constant here, unlike in a country-level comparison where language may matter. That makes the state-level pattern a useful look at non-linguistic factors, though the map alone cannot prove why the clusters form.
How to read this ranking without over-reading it
Use this checklist when reading any AI humor ranking:
- Check the denominator: is the score a share of comments, or a raw count?
- Check the sample: here it was the top 50 threads per state, not every thread.
- Check the exclusions: replies, removed comments and linked comments were removed.
- Separate activity from humor: comments per thread is not a joke percentage.
- Treat regional clusters as a pattern to investigate, not as proof of a cause.
- Remember the label is attempted humor as classified by the model, not a judgement of whether a joke was funny.
| Measure | What it shows | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Average comments per thread | How vocal a state's threads are | Provides the baseline before judging humor shares |
| Share of comments labelled as jokes | Attempted humor among top-level comments | The ranking metric; it reflects attempts, not success or quality |
| Regional clustering on the map | Whether similar scores sit near each other | Suggests possible geographic or cultural factors, without proving causation |
Activity and humor are separate measures; do not infer one from the other.
Frequently asked questions
Which states ranked highest for attempted jokes?
Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Arkansas were at the top of the ranking. The percentages fell gradually through most of the list, with a sharper drop at the bottom for Hawaii, Maine and the Virgin Islands.
Which comments were excluded from the humor classification?
Only direct, top-level comments were classified. Replies to other comments, deleted or removed comments, and comments containing links were excluded, because their context or intent was harder to judge reliably from the thread title alone.
How large was the dataset?
The analysis covered 2,700 threads and 209,806 top-level comments. For each state, comments from the top 50 threads of the year were collected, then classified with the thread topic as context.
Does commenting a lot mean a state jokes more?
Activity and humor are different measures. Maine, for example, was among the most active states by comments per thread but near the bottom for attempted jokes, suggesting more serious discussion there. Hawaii and the Virgin Islands were also less active in the top commenters list.