Skip to content

What US State Subreddits Discuss Most: A GPT-4o-mini Topic Analysis

State subreddits can reveal local preoccupations, but thousands of thread titles are difficult to compare by hand. This analysis classified 50,947 top threads from the past year across US state communities into eight topics, then compared the resulting shares by state. Two themes dominated almost everywhere: news and politics, and nature and culture. The geographic pattern was striking, with the leading theme often changing near the Rocky Mountains in the west and the Appalachian Mountains in the east.

From word cloud to eight fixed categories

A word cloud gives a quick first look by enlarging nouns that appear most often in thread titles. Common and proper nouns were extracted and lemmatized, so the visual emphasizes subjects rather than verbs or filler words. That preliminary view helped shape the final category set before any model-based classification began.

The eight categories were news and politics, classifieds, queries, opinions and rants, nature and culture, sports, humor, and others. Each thread title, with its flair when available, was assigned to exactly one category. Using a fixed label set makes state-by-state percentages comparable and avoids free-form summaries that would be hard to aggregate.

Two themes led almost every state

After classification, every state except Guam and the Virgin Islands had one of two leading categories. News and politics led in many more densely populated areas, while nature and culture led in many lower-density states shaped by mountains, parks, cold climates, or other prominent natural features. The map pattern was geographically continuous rather than scattered randomly, suggesting that place and landscape help explain the split.

A useful way to read the result is to separate two questions. First, what is each state's single largest category? Second, within a chosen category, which states have the highest share? The first question produces the two-color national map. The second produces category-specific rankings, which can reveal smaller themes that never lead a state overall.

News and politics versus nature and culture

News and politics ranged from a little below 20% to a little over 80% across states. California was highest at 83.38%, followed by Illinois at 75.83%, Texas at 75.36%, Ohio at 73.30%, and Virginia at 72.29%. The distribution tracked population density in the captured comparison: denser regions discussed news and politics more, while less populous regions devoted larger shares to other subjects.

Nature and culture showed an almost inverse pattern. Washington led at 74.11%, followed by Arizona at 73.96%, Colorado at 59.19%, Montana at 54.75%, and Alaska at 47.20%. Lower population density, mountainous terrain, and distinctive natural environments were associated with stronger discussion of outdoor and cultural subjects.

Smaller themes show different geographic patterns

Opinions and rants were led by Puerto Rico at 19.43, Iowa at 17.91, Guam at 17.73, the District of Columbia at 14.82, and New Jersey at 14.27. Three of the top five were small, densely populated places, while eastern states were more prominent in the upper part of the ranking. The captured interpretation raised weather as one possible explanation for the east-west difference, but that remains a hypothesis rather than a demonstrated cause.

Queries were led by the Virgin Islands at 77.59% and Guam at 35.15%, followed by Nevada at 24.14%, South Dakota at 17.38%, and Georgia at 15.21%. Small territories may route practical questions to the state-level community, whereas larger states may send similar questions to city or county subreddits. Visitor questions were also suggested as a possible contributor.

Classifieds were led by North Dakota at 7.61, South Dakota at 6.39, Delaware at 6.33, Kentucky at 6.29, and Guam at 6.19. The pattern resembled queries: smaller or less densely populated places appeared more likely to use the state community for hyperlocal utility, including job posts and animal sales. Sports were led by Nevada at 3.11, Hawaii at 2.87, Montana at 2.82, North Dakota at 2.79, and Nebraska at 2.75, with northern states generally stronger and southern-border states weaker. Humor was highly skewed, led by Puerto Rico at 22.40, New Jersey at 15.19, Minnesota at 13.10, Alaska at 11.39, and Maine at 8.79; many other states were close to zero. Language was raised as a question for Puerto Rico's position, not established as an explanation.

A practical checklist for reproducing the analysis

Use this checklist when repeating or auditing the workflow:

  • Start with a state-to-subreddit mapping and skip entries without a subreddit.
  • Collect top threads with a one-year filter and store each thread once.
  • Preserve the title, flair, score, creation time, permalink, body text, and subreddit for later checks.
  • Classify each title into one fixed category, using flair only as a hint.
  • Skip rows already classified so an interrupted run can resume safely.
  • Convert counts into within-state percentages and identify each state's top category.
  • Build noun-only word clouds for all threads and for each category.
  • Merge the percentage table with state geometry before drawing choropleth maps.
  • Report both the national leader map and category-specific top-five tables.

The protected implementation modules are code0001 for data collection, code0002 for structured GPT-4o-mini classification, code0003 for percentage tables, code0004 for word clouds, code0005 for map data preparation, code0006 for the top-category map, and code0007 for category maps and top-five tables. Refer to those module IDs for the exact contract contents.

What the comparison can and cannot show

State size, natural features, language, population density, and geographic position may all shape what a community discusses, but the captured evidence supports associations rather than firm causes. The strongest conclusion is descriptive: news and politics or nature and culture dominated almost every state community, while smaller categories revealed additional local patterns. Structured model output made the large-scale classification practical by returning one predefined label per thread instead of an unstructured summary.

Category leaders at a glance
CategoryLeading statesPattern to notice
News and politicsCalifornia 83.38%; Illinois 75.83%; Texas 75.36%Stronger in denser regions
Nature and cultureWashington 74.11%; Arizona 73.96%; Colorado 59.19%Stronger in lower-density and mountainous regions
QueriesVirgin Islands 77.59%; Guam 35.15%; Nevada 24.14%Small territories dominate
HumorPuerto Rico 22.40%; New Jersey 15.19%; Minnesota 13.10%Highly skewed; many states near zero

Percentages are within-state shares of analyzed threads in the captured analysis.

Frequently asked questions

How many threads were analyzed?

The analysis covered 50,947 threads collected with Reddit's top sorting and a one-year filter across state subreddits.

Which categories were used?

Eight labels were used: news and politics, classifieds, queries, opinions and rants, nature and culture, sports, humor, and others. The others group was excluded from the visualizations.

Which two categories dominated most states?

Except for Guam and the Virgin Islands, each state's leading category was either news and politics or nature and culture.

Which states led the two largest categories?

California led for news and politics at 83.38%, while Washington led for nature and culture at 74.11%.

What tools formed the technical workflow?

Python was used with PRAW for Reddit access, dataset for SQLite storage, pydantic and OpenAI for structured classification, spaCy for noun extraction, pandas for tables, and geopandas, matplotlib and geoplot for maps. The exact protected implementation modules are code0001 through code0007.

statenews and politics
California83.38%
Illinois75.83%
Texas75.36%
Ohio73.3%
Virginia72.29%
statenature and culture
Washington74.11%
Arizona73.96%
Colorado59.19%
Montana54.75%
Alaska47.2%
stateopinions and rants
Puerto Rico19.43
Iowa17.91
Guam17.73
District of Columbia14.82
New Jersey14.27
statequeries
Virgin Islands77.59%
Guam35.15%
Nevada24.14%
South Dakota17.38%
Georgia15.21%
stateclassifieds
North Dakota7.61
South Dakota6.39
Delaware6.33
Kentucky6.29
Guam6.19
statesports
Nevada3.11
Hawaii2.87
Montana2.82
North Dakota2.79
Nebraska2.75
statehumor
Puerto Rico22.4
New Jersey15.19
Minnesota13.1
Alaska11.39
Maine8.79