Skip to content

Which Countries Joke Most on Reddit? AI Humour Analysis by Country

A large language model can turn a vague question about national humour into a measurable one: what share of top-level comments in each country subreddit reads as an attempted joke? This guide explains the dataset, the classification rules, the caveats that change interpretation, and how to reproduce the charts and map.

What the 64% result actually means

The headline result is that the United States and Australia topped the attempted-humour chart at 64%. That figure is a share of valid direct comments classified as jokes, not a measure of how funny anyone is, how often a whole population jokes, or how well jokes landed. A comment counted as a joke only needed to sound humorous or sarcastic in context of its thread title.

Dataset construction in four stages

Start with a country-to-subreddit mapping file, then fetch the year's top 50 threads per subreddit through the Reddit API with PRAW. Store threads in SQLite with a processed flag so a restarted run can resume without repeating finished work. Next, expand each thread's comment forest, flatten replies, and store comment text, parent, submitter status and a blank model-output field. The blank field itself becomes the progress marker for the next stage.

Classification rules and skip logic

For each eligible top-level comment, the prompt contains the thread title, the comment body, and an instruction to answer joke or not joke when the comment sounds humorous or sarcastic in that context. The system instruction restricts output to those two labels, although in practice the model sometimes added explanations. Skip direct replies whose parent identifier begins with t1_, skip deleted or removed text, and skip comments containing links for classification. Linked comments still enter the denominator, because they are treated as legitimate non-joke contributions.

Aggregation checklist

Aggregate at country level: thread count, total comment count, valid direct comments, joke count, comments per thread, and joke percentage. Joke percentage is jokes divided by valid direct comments, multiplied by 100. Before counting a joke, exclude outputs containing not joke or not a joke. Countries below 100 valid direct comments are flagged as insufficient data instead of being ranked on a thin sample.

Volume is not humour: reading the two charts

Two separate rankings answer different questions. Comments per thread shows conversational volume in the sampled top threads. Joke percentage shows the share of eligible comments classified as attempted humour. Eight of the top ten for volume had a significant English-speaking population, while the humour chart was led by the United States and Australia and featured many countries with English speakers or Romanized writing. India, Russia, China and Ukraine appeared in the vocal list but not the top humour list, which may reflect language and script effects rather than lower humour: Romanized native-language writing such as Hinglish may be under-recognised by the model, and some communities may reserve English for formal discussion.

Map, boundaries and exclusions

The map uses World Bank official boundaries under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence, converted from shapefile to GeoJSON and joined to country aggregates by name. Colours form broad geographic bands, with much of Asia in the 35 to 50 percent range, suggesting cultural patterns can cross political borders. England, Scotland and Wales were analysed separately and then removed before mapping because the boundary file lacks their discrete boundaries; Northern Ireland was not separate because r/Ireland is described as island-wide. Northern Cyprus, Transnistria, Abkhazia, Aland, Tokelau and the Cocos Islands were excluded for insufficient data or missing boundaries.

How to interpret the findings responsibly

Use the results as a prompt for further questions, not as a league table of national character. Check the denominator before comparing percentages, check whether a subreddit is a national community or a global discussion forum, and check whether Romanized or mixed-language comments may have been missed. A stronger follow-up would sample comments manually per country, test the classifier on Romanized native-language examples, and report uncertainty for low-volume subreddits.

Field map for the country aggregates
MeasureNumeratorDenominatorUse it to judge
Comments per threadTotal commentsThreads obtainedConversational volume in sampled top threads
Joke percentageComments classified as jokeValid direct commentsShare of eligible comments that are attempted jokes
Valid direct commentsTop-level comments not deleted, removed or redactedAll retrieved commentsWhether a country has enough eligible data to rank

Joke percentage is only comparable when valid direct comments are sufficient; below 100 the map marks not enough data.

Frequently asked questions

What data was analysed?

The analysis collected the year's top 50 threads from each country subreddit, retrieved their comments, and used Mistral 7B to label top-level comments as joke or not joke in context of the thread title. In total, 352,686 comments from 9,969 threads were covered.

Does a country subreddit represent that country's people?

Subreddit membership does not prove citizenship or residence. The example given is r/northkorea, a global discussion community, while North Korean citizens have severely limited internet access. Treat results as subreddit behaviour, not a national trait.

Which comments were excluded from joke classification?

Direct replies to other comments were skipped because title context alone is insufficient, as were deleted or removed comments. Comments containing links were skipped for classification but counted in the denominator, because a linked comment is treated as a serious, supported point rather than a likely joke.

Why do some countries show no percentage?

Countries with fewer than 100 valid direct comments were marked as not enough data on the map, rather than given a reliable percentage.

How were inconsistent model outputs handled?

The model sometimes returned explanations and the variant 'not a joke' instead of only 'not joke'. Classification therefore checked for 'not joke' and 'not a joke' before counting a comment containing 'joke' as a joke.